[發問] 真的是垃圾?

http://www.chick.com/zh/b5/default.asp#tracts

最近,這個網站裡的言論在[離教者之家]鬧得沸沸揚揚;我湊熱鬧,也點擊上去看看。網站內原來還有其他漫畫;因為好奇,所以看了一點。
看著看著,覺得很奇怪。我發覺,裡面的信息主要是宣揚一種仇恨的情緒:對世界的仇恨,對不信者、甚至其他信仰的仇恨,其次才強調人的原罪,及上帝差遣耶穌來為人贖罪之類的信息。
漫畫裡有不少情節,都將[不信者]和[反耶教者]暗暗地拉上關係,甚至劃上等號;不信的,就一定很討厭耶教教徒,對耶教教義嗤之以鼻。而所有飾演不信者的角色,都被描繪成面目猙獰、可厭可憎的人物。他們只會憤然抨擊相信耶教教義的人,所有耶教的言論都聽不入耳;然而,到劇情要交待他們相信耶教時,他們卻反過來,不斷以自責、懺悔,哭哭啼啼,拋棄以前一直堅持相信的一切。
這種情節,看上去好像是在用[峰迴路轉]的表達手法;只是,用得有點突兀,以致整體故事變得很詭異、邪派。而且,內裡那種[善行不能救你]的思想,暗示了只要奉上帝之名,即使作惡也可以;這種言論對世界確是非常危險的。
不過,就整個宣傳手法來看,我看到一個相反的意思。以平常人的心態去看,大家都看到裡面各種荒謬、扭曲的邏輯;如果要靠這種思想宣傳耶教,除非宣傳的社區與世隔絕,而且整個社區的傳媒都完全配合,鋪天蓋地控制言論,否則只要用現實中的理性對照,就可得知當中各種錯誤,甚至危險。而且,這種與普遍耶教的宣傳,強調[神就是愛、包容、寬恕]的手法比較,是背道而馳的。所以,我反而覺得,這個網站是反耶教的組織所造的——看上去像是宣傳耶教教義,藉耶教將自己放上一個道德高地;背後卻是指出、強調當中荒謬之處,叫大家對耶教敬而遠之,甚至感到討厭。
這確是一種很高明的宣傳手法。一邊可以令奉行耶教教義的信徒,看上去不會感到有問題;另一邊卻同時令有理性的人對耶教有所反感。這條鋼線,不易踏;而這網站,就是其中一個教材,一個成功的例子。

[ 本帖最後由 酒井明 於 2007-8-29 15:05 編輯 ]
Alessa is a daughter of Dahlia Gillespie. Alessa gets toasted in a ritual. Alessa is in agony. Alessa sends a part of her soul (the pure part, the part that wouldn't have to suffer) away in a form of a baby abandoned on the road. Harry finds the baby with his wife. They name her Cheryl.

The rest of it... You know.

回復 #2 抽刀斷水 的帖子

所以我強調,這種思想一定要在一個與世隔絕、輿論完全地被控制的社區進行,才能做到真正的思想控制,將這種不為世人所容的思想強行殖入一個人的腦袋裡。
只是,大前提是我假設人有一定的理智思考基礎,會對身邊任何媒體信息有一定的批判能力;這網站的信息,一看就感到討厭了,又怎會達到宣傳效果?直到廿一世紀,人類經歷過這麼多場因為過份激進思想引起的戰爭,各種教訓歷歷在目,歷史書裡自有明言,相信早就對這種言論有了戒心。只要一被輿論所報道,就會有不少學者出來指出當中各種荒謬和危險,正統教派也會有公關出來說項,淡化這種耶教思想。所以我認為,這種宣傳於普遍來說,是很難有效果的。
當然,一個社區要真的做到[與世隔絕]、[輿論完全地被控制],真的要做的話,其實,不算太困難......
Alessa is a daughter of Dahlia Gillespie. Alessa gets toasted in a ritual. Alessa is in agony. Alessa sends a part of her soul (the pure part, the part that wouldn't have to suffer) away in a form of a baby abandoned on the road. Harry finds the baby with his wife. They name her Cheryl.

The rest of it... You know.
原帖由 沙文 於 2007-8-29 13:40 發表
咁又冇乜危險嘅。我向來都冇諗住要靠善行得救架啦


咁你個人對世界冇殺傷力嘛,而且,得唔得救,只係耶教入面o既野,你係唔buy架嘛。當然,你個人會唔會做善行呢就........
Alessa is a daughter of Dahlia Gillespie. Alessa gets toasted in a ritual. Alessa is in agony. Alessa sends a part of her soul (the pure part, the part that wouldn't have to suffer) away in a form of a baby abandoned on the road. Harry finds the baby with his wife. They name her Cheryl.

The rest of it... You know.

回復 #7 沙文 的帖子

對你呢種人冇危險o者,但係,唔係每個人都好似你咁,咁高班架嘛!如果唔係,普通法裡面就唔會有一條叫做[煽動罪]啦,係咪?
Alessa is a daughter of Dahlia Gillespie. Alessa gets toasted in a ritual. Alessa is in agony. Alessa sends a part of her soul (the pure part, the part that wouldn't have to suffer) away in a form of a baby abandoned on the road. Harry finds the baby with his wife. They name her Cheryl.

The rest of it... You know.

回復 #9 沙文 #10 Step.King 的帖子

我記得就係囉......睇報紙睇過,話如果係一班人圍住一個或幾個人黎dup,即使周圍o既人只係響度叫囂吶喊冇郁手,一樣可以告得入,罪名就係[煽動罪]。記得係咁上下;當然,要搵一D識法律o既人問問啦。
Alessa is a daughter of Dahlia Gillespie. Alessa gets toasted in a ritual. Alessa is in agony. Alessa sends a part of her soul (the pure part, the part that wouldn't have to suffer) away in a form of a baby abandoned on the road. Harry finds the baby with his wife. They name her Cheryl.

The rest of it... You know.
即係........即係其實冇關係!噢!
Alessa is a daughter of Dahlia Gillespie. Alessa gets toasted in a ritual. Alessa is in agony. Alessa sends a part of her soul (the pure part, the part that wouldn't have to suffer) away in a form of a baby abandoned on the road. Harry finds the baby with his wife. They name her Cheryl.

The rest of it... You know.
高級模式 | 發新話題
B Color Image Link Quote Code Smilies
換一個