返回列表 回覆 發帖

無神論的論據之一:Unexpected benefit are often happier

Consider the following scenario: If God and afterlife are real

If we believe god and afterlife, and after we death , we face the situation as expected.  No unexpected return or gain.

If we believe no afterlife and even no god, after death, we earned unexpected benefit and return.

Many people say unexpected benefit are more happier than expected return
If god and after life not exists, believer waste many time and money as well as emotional and mental resources
The believer can earn more than atheist only if the god requires us to believe, but this means god is not loving all people, no empathy, and play "hide and seek" game with human, and reward only to people who successfully find him in this hide and seek game.
However, no religion god in the world say their god are like that.
Consider the following scenario: If God and afterlife are real

If we believe god and afterlife, and ...
Guest from 124.217.137.x 發表於 2023/8/14 20:34


這是偏頗的,因為這是無視其他宗教。假如其他宗教如回/猶,把耶穌當神崇拜的教徒,絕對不會有幸福的回報了。
回覆 4#[/url] 昊暠昺

假設神存在,神要求我們信祂,信才能得救:咁信神才明智。

但咁代表神不是愛世人,對人類沒有同理心,跟人類玩捉迷藏遊戲,甚至像隨機選擇幸運儀一樣。呢個唔係無可能,但會跟所有宗教對神的描述,即「神愛世人」發生衝突。

假設神存在,神沒有要求我們信祂:

有神論者和無神論者,皆有來世,但有神論者無驚喜,無神論者有驚喜。通常有驚喜的禮物會更快樂。此外,無神論者可以專注今世,無需有額外的擔憂。
假設神存在
Guest from 124.217.137.x 發表於 2023/8/15 13:44



    是假設「什麼宗教定義的神」存在呢?
回覆6# 抽刀斷水


一般而言,神指
1)創造者:宇宙創造者;或太陽系創造者;或地球創造者;或地球生命創造者;或人類創造者;或
2)管理者:宇宙管理者;或太陽系管理者;或地球管理者;或地球生命管理者;或人類管理者;或
3)有強大超自然力量並對人類生活可以有重大影響及作出積極的干預(神仙)
一般而言,若果要用are, 必須係benefits
Don't know where God is but the Devil is in the details
3)有強大超自然力量並對人類生活可以有重大影響及作出積極的干預(神仙)
Guest from 124.217.137.x 發表於 2023/8/15 15:51



    睇完Oppenheimer,睇你呢點就聯想到係核彈。
返回列表
高級模式 | 發新話題
B Color Image Link Quote Code Smilies
換一個