I will make an attempt on this one
"問：進化論不可靠。
答：為何肺癆箘受藥後，會變成帶抗藥性？
我答：若果可以以肺癆箘受藥後變成帶抗藥性一個現象來支持整個進化論，那是極度不科學的。要知道有極多的現象是進化論至今仍未能解釋的，詳看本站另頁或參考《進化論批判》《科學創造論》《Darwin Retried -- An Appeal to Reason》《創世以來的奧祕》等書。再說，創造論也可以解釋這一現象，「神創造了一種菌，受藥後帶抗藥性」，這解釋最少不能被反證。(請試試看)"
肺癆箘 is only one of the example. Your immune system is another example. Cancer is another example. The dog you see is another examples. There are ample evidence for evolution.
Creationism can explain as much as magic can explain. That is why it is not science. (Reminder, the fact that certain magic is not falsifiable is a handicap.)
-------------
PS. The evolutionary root pointed out about 肺癆箘 is important. It shows the direction of how the disease should be treated, for example
1) Take all your medicine to ensure that all 肺癆箘 is kill in the first attempt (instead of providing them with generation to evolve). The Hospital Authority in HK is already recommending that without telling you much about the science behind it.
2) Use "cocktail treatment" in occasional cases, when you can predict their evolution. Like chess, you can push the bateria into "deadends" and cut all their evolve path
3) If you plan to use stronger drug, use it on the first attempt instead of increasing it step by step because it gives the bateria generation to evolve
4) For advance understand, do understand that coughing is a evolved behaviour of human to get rid of unwanted stuff in the system, but is abused by the bateria for its own genetic purpose. So cure the symptom if it is 肺癆箘 for benefit of the other human. If it is something else that causes the coughing, examine the root cause because as unpleasant as it is, coughing can be good for you sometimes.
5) Finally, 肺癆箘 do evolve naturally. There will always be new strand coming out. Doctors and researcher should always keep their eyes open. |
2011/10/11 12:58
| 
2011/10/11 21:30
| 
