沙文

各位去飲宴,食蝦時會見到waiter拎一盅茶上枱,若然您大鄉里飲咗佢,實畀人笑到面黃。
https://v.qq.com/x/page/j0707haqu57.html

在經書中亦有咁嘅笑料:
2:6 照猶太人潔淨的規矩、有六口石缸擺在那裡、每口可以盛兩三桶水。
2:7耶穌對用人說、把缸倒滿了水．他們就倒滿了、直到缸口。
2:8耶穌又說、現在可以舀出來、送給管筵席的．他們就送了去。
2:9管筵席的嘗了那水變的酒、並不知道是那裡來的、只有舀水的用人知道．管筵席的便叫新郎來、
2:11這是耶穌所行的頭一件神蹟、是在加利利的迦拿行的、顯出他的榮耀來．他的門徒就信他了。

在此事件中,飲酒嘅guests係唔知尐酒喺點黎嘅。點解阿穌唔敢畀人知呢?
其實,嗰六個缸嘅水,係用來咁様做的:

At a wedding were set vessels of various sizes to wash hands and feet in; there was one vessel called which the gloss says was a large pitcher, or basin, out of which the whole company washed their hands and their feet; and there was another called which was a lesser and beautiful basin, which was set alone for the more honourable persons, as for the bride, and for any gentlewoman (w); and such might be these six stone jars, or pots:
https://biblehub.com/commentaries/john/2-6.htm



所以,飲咗用這些缸水變嘅酒,仲衰過飲以上講的洗手水,因為仲要洗埋腳。

沙文

靚女玉足踩出來就好啫,
https://kknews.cc/food/vaa2kg2.html

去飲嘅3山5嶽,我就唔制

沙文

as usual, 經書古仔充滿破绽, 大家有否發覺這古仔衰邊度呢?
管筵席的便叫新郎來、對他說、人都是先擺上好酒．等客喝足了、纔擺上次的．你倒把好酒留到如今。

其實,猶太傳統, wedding banquet嘅planning 同畀錢都係女家負責嘅, 這個傳統甚至延續到今日的基督教文化:
"Since it was usual for the bride’s parents to pay for the wedding, they often took charge of planning the occasion according to their taste and budget. "
https://www.myjewishlearning.com ... ituals-for-parents/
https://www.theknot.com/content/wedding-budget-who-pays-for-what
https://www.cnn.com/2013/10/18/living/matrimony-who-pays-for-what/index.html

寫經人顯然冇留意這個傳统, 作古仔都唔識作, 唔怪得之猶太佬唔信新约

沙文

梗係唔係啦。耶稣時代邊個負奏畀酒席就係猶太佬自己最清楚,唔通猫猶太佬唔知要您至知。若然佢寫得個古仔咁啱, 後世嘅猫太佬就唔會咁抗拒新约啦。

其實經書情節所寫的Interpersonal relationship一貫地係好幼稚的。
"耶穌又說、現在可以舀出來、送給管筵席的．他們就送了去。" 阿稣只不過係guest, 唔係事頭。waiters點解要聽佢支笛? 尐酒來歷不明, 若然飲死人, waiters同banquet manager咪孭晒鑊
https://www.ettoday.net/news/20190224/1385378.htm

所以, 唯一合理解釋就係: "耶穌對用人說、把缸倒滿了水．他們就倒滿了、直到缸口。" 根本佢地就收咗水串通, 倒落洗腳缸嘅係酒, 佢地先會咁肯定冇事。

沙文

會咖, 通常叫pitcher beer

沙文

耶穌母親一早就到咗，　仲早過耶穌同門徒。。。
普通客人使唔使咁早到呢？　（又無雀局打四圈）

beebeechan 發表於 2019/2/24 07:03

所以話雞涿徒個個充猶太佬, 其實唔識嘢, 人地结婚结成7日, 第3日其實房都洞埋, 黎嘅都係好疏堂嘅哎吔親戚或點頭之交
Marriage ceremonies – After the period of the betrothal was finished and all the agreements were at last reached and signed, the wedding could take place. Weddings typically extended over a period of five to seven days. Autumn was the best time for marriages: the harvest was in, the vintage over, minds were free, and hearts were at rest. It was a season when the evenings were cool and delightful and it was agreeable to sit up late at night. Usually the entire village gathered for a wedding.
http://blog.adw.org/2014/08/what-were-weddings-like-in-jesus-day/

沙文

大家再睇多一項waiter心路歷程分析,便知此乃鐡定騙局。

阿稣叫waiter倒「水」入洗腳缸,然後不畀經理飲。

若果倒落洗腳缸的係水,侍仔就會諗: 若果經理飲嘅係洗腳水,咁都唔炒就天冇眼。

所以,佢在不畀經理飲之前一定已肯定係酒而非洗腳水。而要肯定呢様嘢,佢必需要試飲一啖。

但係經文冇話侍仔有咁樣做喎。所以我们可以肯定,佢①早知道倒入缸嘅係酒！

沙文

經文無講既野，　由你斷估呀？
beebeechan 發表於 2019/2/25 07:25

您都係啫, 根本冇真憑實據阿稣時代猶太佬娶老婆係同而家相反,由男家找酒席數。
或者您同大家分享下您識得邊條猶太佬咁笨7
猶太佬最中意嘅冧把亦係笨7個7, 並唔係3, 3只算普普通通, 冇7咁好。
https://www.myjewishlearning.com/article/judaism-numbers/

沙文

點解唔直接倒酒俾客人，　要先倒入缸，　
個缸又本來都唔係要嚟貯酒既
beebeechan 發表於 2019/2/25 07:28

因為直接倒酒俾客人，就畀人睇出其實佢根本只不過係serving買番黎嘅酒
先將買番黎嘅酒倒入洗腳缸, 咁就冇咁覺眼係買番黎
即是譬如我老婆買外賣呃我話佢自己煮, 都要先銷毁外賣盒transfer去屋企嘅碟

沙文

回覆 22# beebeechan
您都話冇問題就得啦。咁事情就好易明, 阿稣係用買番嚟既酒請客, case closed

沙文

猶太人視一週第三日係婚事吉日, 係同創世紀有關既,
beebeechan 發表於 2019/2/25 17:14

您老作都要follow下經書。
第6日先致有人, 第3日结碌葛咩
第3日啱啱整完植物, 真係碌葛就有得結

沙文

從畫中人物既衣著嚟睇
最3山5嶽都耶穌同佢班門徒
beebeechan 發表於 2019/2/25 17:47

係呀, 佢地有份用洗腳缸洗腳, 而且對腳零舍污糟

凡不接待你們、不聽你們話的人、你們離開那家、或是那城的時候、就把腳上的塵土跺下去。

沙文

嗱,咁大家就清楚睇住尐水如何冲過對香港手/腳,然後連埋膿及踩到嘅屎等一齊流返入缸
門徒就咁玩法

沙文

瑪竇福音22章就講有個國王娶新袍, 同個仔擺酒請客,
僕人四圍去請賓客都無人黎....(怕係唔想做人情, 話唔得閒黎卦, 猶如90後話齋, 做唔到一千蚊人情, 不如唔好黎!)
於是在路口, 凡遇到的，無論壞人好人，都召集了來，婚宴上就滿了坐席的人
(呢餐唔知係男家俾錢定係女家出錢既呢?)
beebeechan 發表於 2019/2/25 16:21

"Since it was usual for the bride’s parents to pay for the wedding, they often took charge of planning the occasion according to their taste and budget. "
https://www.myjewishlearning.com ... ituals-for-parents/
若果係中國皇帝就中國規例,若果係猶太皇帝就猶太例。。但照聖教會詮釋, 天國係international的, 咁就未必一定係猶太皇帝
22:1耶穌又用比喻對他們說、
22:2天國好比一個王、為他兒子擺設娶親的筵席。

但迦拿事件就講明係猶太佬娶親
"照猶太人潔淨的規矩、有六口石缸擺在那裡、每口可以盛兩三桶水。"

沙文

回覆 32# beebeechan
傳統習俗彌足珍貴之處就係咁歷久常新

沙文

回覆 34# beebeechan

咁又唔駛成日referendum. 您問阿稣請佢講清楚"22:2天國好比一個王、" 究竟係乜國嘅王

沙文

門口有盆就用盆,有缸就用缸,有塔就用塔。 就手就得啦

沙文

馬褂未夠傳统,我中意呢尐姐姐
https://cn.nytimes.com/china/201 ... s-clothing/zh-hant/

沙文

回覆 39# beebeechan

咁事情就清楚了。天皇地點
    https://kb.51.ca/item/191

此處正是女家畀酒席費
https://www.englishforums.com/En ... rUsa/zmxwp/post.htm

沙文

回覆 44# beebeechan

https://abcnews.go.com/Health/se ... p/story?id=14014446